Apple and Google were fined R$19 million in Brazil for allowing FaceApp to improperly collect user data. A court ruled that both companies contributed to the app’s violations of Brazilian privacy laws. FaceApp has previously faced criticism for its data practices. Both companies may appeal the ruling, which emphasizes their responsibility in user data protection.
Apple and Google have been penalized by a Brazilian court, being fined approximately R$19 million (around US$3.1 million) due to their involvement in the distribution of FaceApp, an image editing application. The ruling by Judge Douglas de Melo Martins found that both companies contributed to the unauthorized collection of user data by FaceApp, which is alleged to violate Brazil’s Civil Rights Framework for the Internet. The judge emphasized that Apple and Google have a significant role in the consumer chain, providing essential infrastructure and conditions that enabled FaceApp’s operation.
Despite this ruling, Google has contested the decision, arguing that its involvement is limited to distributing applications through the Google Play Store, asserting that it holds no responsibility for FaceApp’s terms of service. Nonetheless, the judge’s determination suggests that the tech giants facilitated the app’s breaches of Brazilian law. Both Apple and Google retain the option to appeal the ruling in a higher court.
FaceApp, widely recognized for its features allowing users to alter and enhance their photographs with various effects, gained notoriety among younger audiences. It previously faced scrutiny in 2019 for allegedly storing users’ photographs without their approval and was labeled a potential security risk by the FBI due to its affiliation with Russian developers. The application remains available on both platforms for free, although it features in-app purchases that can amount to a significant expense.
The background of this legal issue involves concerns regarding user privacy and data security, particularly within the realm of mobile applications. FaceApp has been mired in controversy since its inception, criticized for its data collection practices and ties to potentially insecure entities. In Brazil, the legal framework governing internet rights emphasizes protecting user data, making the responsibilities of platforms like Apple and Google in relation to third-party applications increasingly scrutinized. The outcome of this case could set a precedence for how technology companies are held accountable for third-party app usage in terms of user protection and data privacy.
The decision to fine Apple and Google highlights the ongoing challenges tech companies face regarding user data protection. As they navigate the legal landscape surrounding privacy rights, the implications of this ruling may influence future policies and practices regarding app distribution and user consent. Furthermore, it sheds light on the accountability of major tech platforms for the actions of apps they enable, particularly in light of increasing scrutiny on privacy and data security worldwide.
Original Source: 9to5mac.com
